
A case study based on the recent allegations on IndusViva
September 16: Direct Selling refers to marketing, distribution and sale of goods or providing services through a network of people. The roots of Direct Selling can be trailed back to the United States of America, which is known as the ‘Motherland of Direct Selling’. Unfortunately, the growth and success of this industry led to the development of fraud money circulation schemes in the name of Direct Selling. Since its inception, the industry has started facing several issues. It is often mistaken as a money chain or money circulation because there is a thin line between the two, similar to water and acid. You can’t distinguish if you don’t taste it. The absence of specific laws and norms to regulate direct selling companies was the reason behind this misconception. The ordinary people failed to notice the significant difference between Direct Selling and money circulation; the former compensate the direct sellers based on the sales volume generated, whereas the latter pays merely based on the recruitment.
In 1979, one of the pioneering companies in the Direct Selling industry, Amway, was identified as a legitimate business organization by the US Federal Trade Commission. Still, it took few decades for this giant to get this clean chit.
During the mid-1990s, the new model of economic reforms known as LPG, Liberalization, Privatization and Globalization model posed a boon for increasing revenue. In this period, Direct Selling made its way into the country with global companies like Oriflame, Amway, Avon, etc., followed by Indian companies, which became industry giants later. However, it continued to face challenges at every step. Time and again, it became mistaken as fraudulent Pyramid or Ponzi schemes. With the progress in the Direct Selling industry, money chain and money circulation schemes started taking birth just like unwanted weeds in paddy fields. People were lured in the name of quick and easy money, similar to mirages on a summer afternoon. FICCI, in association with KPMG, studied and highlighted the following causes due to this ignorance:
- Amendment in the PCMCS Act
- Need to streamline FDI policy
- Need for a clear definition
- Need for a governing legislation
- Need for a nodal ministry
The industry witnessed a revolution by issuing Direct Selling Guidelines 2016 and this new fiscal restructuring by the then Government of India through the Ministry of Consumer Affairs, under the ministry of Late Ram Vilas Paswan. It changed the horoscope of the industry altogether. Consisting of the guiding principles for State Governments to consider Direct Selling as regular businesses and appointing a monitoring mechanism to prevent any fraud in the best interests of the people involved in the business or customers was the main highlight. Following the guidelines, many states involved in this business has appointed a nodal authority for strict supervision.
Direct Selling is a retailing chain for marketing products and services directly to the consumers or customers, and people involved in this business are called Direct Sellers. According to Consumer Protection Act 2019, it is a legal, economic activity that helps entrepreneurs build a business by working self-reliantly with less overhead costs. The Act also endorses MLM while defining that when a person buys, he becomes a consumer. Multi-Level Marketing is a kind of direct selling in which a direct seller is paid compensation for the sales generated and the sales of their direct selling network who they recruit or sponsor directly or indirectly, referred to as ‘downline’. The term carries a negative image widely, whereas the Act endorsed it and their network of Direct Sellers. This business has gained momentum as the Direct Selling industry provides an alternative employment opportunity. People can enjoy financial freedom by earning a commission from the sale of products or services. It has paved the way for women empowerment and taken up several CSR initiatives. As per an existing report, the Indian Direct Selling Market is around INR 72 billion and is estimated to reach around INR 645 billion by 2025.
Although there is a guideline and most state governments have appointed monitoring mechanisms, the absence of an exclusive law still led to the discriminatory approach of people or authority, and they are unable to distinguish between legitimate Multi-level Marketing companies and fraudulent money circulation schemes. It is hopeful for the industry that the Ministry of Consumer Affairs (Direct Selling Rules 2021) shall help. According to Direct Selling Guidelines 2016 (Clause 1.7), a Direct Selling entity is not engaged in a pyramid scheme that sells or offers to sell goods or services through a direct seller. In the Guidelines, Clause 1, Sub-clause 11, the first paragraph defines the Pyramid scheme, and the second paragraph clearly explains how Direct Selling is different from Pyramid Scheme by laying down few conditions. Even after the clarity provided in the Guidelines, as mentioned above, misinterpretation by the law enforcement agencies continued. For example, one of India’s leading Direct Selling companies, IndusViva Health Sciences Private Limited, situated in Bangalore, fell prey to legal issues despite abiding by all the rules and regulations. Established in 2014, it complies with the Central Direct Selling Guidelines-2016, Telangana State Direct Selling Guidelines2017 and is registered as per Companies Act-2013. When Kerala Govt. issued their first Multi-level Marketing guidelines on 14th September 2015, regarding Kerala Finance Bill 2015, according to Kerala Value Added Tax (KVAT) Act, 2003, which was the first of its kind. IndusViva got the first registration as per the guidelines mentioned above and the first direct selling company to be legalized by any state government. It is enlisted in the provisional list of direct selling entities published by the Ministry of Consumer Affairs after due scrutiny, hence stands upright as a legal entity. With valid and authorized certifications, IndusViva conforms with the Consumer Protection Act 2019 and the Direct Selling Guidelines 2016.
How DS Guidelines distinguishes the Money Chain? However, the time taken to prove the legitimacy, many damages already happened to building business and destroyed lakhs of career. IndusViva and other such companies are getting trapped due to which expert opinion is required because expertise is lacking on the part of the police. Let’s analyse- Direct selling guidelines 2016 has differentiated the pyramid scheme based on enrolment and direct selling (Clause 1, sub-clause 11: a-g).
Provided that the above definition of “Pyramid Scheme” will not apply to a multi-layered network of subscribers to scheme formed by Direct Selling Entity, which consists of subscribers enrolling one or more subscribers to receive the benefit, directly or indirectly, where the benefit is a result of the sale of goods or services by subscribers and the scheme/financial arrangement complies with all of the following:
A) It has no provision that Direct Sellers will receive remuneration or incentives for the recruitment/enrolment of new participants.
B) It does not require the participant to purchase goods or services:
(i)for an amount that exceeds the amount for which such goods or services can be expected to be sold or resold to consumers;
(ii)for the quantity of goods or services that exceeds an amount which can be expected to be consumed, or sold or resold to consumers;
C) It does not require participants to pay any entry/registration fee, cost of sales demonstration equipment and materials or other fees relating to participation;
D) It provides participants with a written contract describing the “material terms” of participation;
E) It allows or provides for a participant a reasonable cooling-off period to participate or cancel participation in the scheme and receive a refund of any consideration given to participate in the operations;
F) It allows or provides for a buy-back or repurchase policy for “currently marketable” goods or services sold to participants at the request of the participants at reasonable terms;
G) It establishes a grievance redressal mechanism for consumers, more particularly described in Clause 7 herein.
Verification based on these conditions, it can be concluded that whether a company is a legitimate Direct Selling/ Multi-level Marketing company or a Ponzi Scheme. In the same manner, it can be clearly understood that IndusViva Health Sciences Pvt. Ltd. is not a money circulation scheme.
There are nodal authorities appointed in several states to govern, alert, and monitor the entire structure just for the namesake. Still, it’s not functioning the way it is expected to do in specific states like Telangana. Some of the designated departments even refused to accept companies’ undertakings as specified in the Direct Selling Guidelines issued by the government of the same state. Therefore, there should be a central monitoring authority with counterparts at the state level, including experts who can distinguish between Direct Selling/ Multi-level Marketing and Ponzi scheme/ Money circulation schemes. For instance, there’s IRDA for insurance companies, SEBI for stock exchange.
You’re so awesome! I do not believe I’ve truly read something
like this before. So great to discover someone with some genuine thoughts on this subject matter.
Seriously.. thanks for starting this up. This website is something that’s needed on the web,
someone with a little originality! https://goegyx5.wixsite.com/my-site-69
Damn i been making soo much money because of this
side hustle totosite? try it out and you will be satisfied
levaquin drug levofloxacin 500mg canada
order avodart 0.5mg generic celebrex 100mg us purchase ondansetron sale
aldactone oral order spironolactone without prescription diflucan cheap
ampicillin 250mg without prescription erythromycin for sale online buy erythromycin 250mg sale
fildena buy online buy fildena 50mg online methocarbamol over the counter
purchase suhagra pill cheap estradiol buy estrace without prescription
buy lamictal 50mg pills buy generic lamictal order tretinoin cream online cheap
tadalis tablet voltaren 100mg drug diclofenac 100mg uk
buy generic isotretinoin order accutane 10mg generic zithromax 250mg brand
indomethacin without prescription order indocin 50mg buy trimox 500mg online
cialis 40mg cheap Approved viagra cheap viagra pill
order anastrozole for sale cheapest generic viagra uk viagra pills 100mg
cialis 20mg gГ©nГ©rique generique viagra 25mg sildenafil 200mg en ligne
prednisone without prescription generic cialis price real viagra pills
tadalafil 20mg kaufen tadalafil 5mg für männer sildenafil 50mg bestellen
purchase isotretinoin pills azithromycin generic stromectol 0.5 mg
buy doxycycline 100mg for sale purchase furosemide online cheap buy furosemide 40mg generic
clonidine 0.1 mg over the counter order spiriva pill order tiotropium bromide 9 mcg sale
buspirone 10mg uk oxybutynin 5mg canada order ditropan 5mg online cheap
order generic hytrin 1mg terazosin drug order azulfidine 500mg
fosamax pill famotidine uk purchase pepcid without prescription
tacrolimus medication buy generic ropinirole 2mg buy urso 150mg online cheap
buy isosorbide generic brand digoxin buy telmisartan 20mg
zyban pills strattera 25mg cost seroquel 100mg cheap
order molnupiravir for sale prevacid cost order prevacid 15mg
buy zoloft 50mg online Overnight delivery viagra purchase sildenafil
oral imuran 100 mcg order pantoprazole 20mg sale viagra 50mg without prescription
tadalafil 40mg ca Cialis buy online viagra 50mg us
how much is cialis tadalafil us symmetrel 100 mg ca
buy naltrexone 50 mg sale generic naltrexone aripiprazole cost
avlosulfon 100 mg without prescription order generic allegra perindopril 8mg uk
medroxyprogesterone without prescription order provera 5mg online purchase periactin without prescription
modafinil 200mg tablet online pharmacy meds ivermectin 0.1
order fluvoxamine sale cymbalta 40mg sale buy glipizide
buy accutane 40mg generic buy prednisone 40mg for sale cheap prednisone
buy nootropil online cheap buy piracetam 800 mg pill buy sildenafil generic
buy zithromax pill order prednisolone 5mg generic generic gabapentin 800mg
cialis for sale online cheap generic sildenafil real viagra 100mg
lasix 100mg over the counter buy doxycycline 200mg pill purchase plaquenil pills
order tadalafil without prescription buy clomipramine generic order clomipramine 25mg sale
order chloroquine 250mg generic order cenforce oral baricitinib 2mg
oral sporanox 100 mg buy sporanox 100 mg for sale purchase tindamax pill
purchase zyprexa generic nebivolol price brand diovan 80mg
norvasc 10mg us cialis 40mg for sale order cialis 10mg online
clozaril 50mg pills dexamethasone 0,5 mg brand buy decadron 0,0,5 mg pill
buy sildenafil 100mg pills order generic sildenafil 100mg purchase lisinopril generic
cost omeprazole 20mg slot online gambling online
order linezolid pill zyvox 600mg ca online roulette for real money
lopressor pill purchase vardenafil generic order vardenafil for sale
paperwriter legitimate online slots for money poker sites
levitra 20mg canada pregabalin drug methylprednisolone order online
online assignment help write my thesis buy viagra 50mg online cheap
buy clomiphene 100mg for sale albuterol price best online casino
cialis overnight shipping usa tadalafil 40mg for sale sildenafil 50mg brand
buy triamcinolone claritin 10mg oral desloratadine usa
dapoxetine 90mg usa misoprostol generic order generic synthroid 100mcg
cialis online tadalafil 40mg without prescription purchase sildenafil pills
order orlistat 60mg generic diltiazem 180mg drug order acyclovir 800mg generic
cialis 40mg usa propranolol canada order plavix generic
purchase allopurinol buy rosuvastatin online cheap zetia oral
order methotrexate 10mg pills buy metoclopramide 20mg generic order reglan 20mg
domperidone medication purchase flexeril pill oral flexeril
order cozaar sale nexium 20mg over the counter topamax 100mg price
generic lioresal buy lioresal for sale buy ketorolac pill
brand imitrex 25mg order generic avodart 0.5mg order avodart generic
order colchicine without prescription best casinos blackjack game
zantac 300mg ca meloxicam 15mg oral cheap celecoxib 100mg
where can i play poker online betfair casino online poker online for money
flomax 0.4mg usa ondansetron 4mg brand aldactone ca
buy simvastatin 10mg for sale order simvastatin 10mg generic proscar pills
buy diflucan 100mg online cheap free shipping viagra purchase sildenafil generic
keflex 250mg cheap cleocin us oral erythromycin 500mg
order tadalafil 10mg pill viagra 50mg cheap sildenafil 150 mg
viagra sildenafil 200mg viagra 100mg oral cheap cialis pills
buy cefuroxime 250mg purchase careprost pills buy robaxin online cheap
online blackjack with real money free spins no deposit usa order tadalafil 5mg pill
brand desyrel 50mg suhagra 100mg over the counter sildenafil 50mg brand
sildenafil citrate 50mg purchase lamictal lamotrigine us
buy deltasone sale order amoxil 250mg amoxil 1000mg ca
usa viagra overnight viagra tablets tadalafil 20mg ca
rivers casino best ed medication tadalafil 10mg pill
order generic zithromax 250mg purchase prednisolone buy gabapentin 800mg sale
betfair casino online order stromectol 3mg pill provigil 200mg price
buy furosemide 100mg sale buy doxycycline online cheap hydroxychloroquine 400mg oral